Military expenditure and Granger causality: A critical review

Dunne, J. P. and Smith, R. P. (2010) Military expenditure and Granger causality: A critical review. Defence and Peace Economics, 21 (5-6). pp. 427-441. ISSN 1024-2694 Available from:

PDF - Accepted Version

Publisher's URL:


A large literature has used tests for Granger (1969) non-causality, GNC, to examine the interaction of military spending with the economy. Such tests answer a specific though quite limited question: can one reject the null hypothesis that one variable does not help predict another? If this null is rejected, there is said to be Granger causality, GC. Although the limitations of GNC tests are well known, they are often not emphasised in the applied literature and so may be forgotten. This paper considers the econometric and methodological issues involved and illustrates them with data for the US and other countries. There are three main issues. First, the tests may not be informative about the substantive issue, the interaction of military expenditure and the economy. The difficulty is that Granger causality, incremental predictability, does not correspond to the usual notion of economic causality. To determine the relationship of the two notions of causality requires an identified structural model. Second, the tests are very sensitive to specification. GNC testing is usually done in the context of a vector autoregression, VAR, and the test results are sensitive to the variables and deterministic terms included in the VAR, lag length, sample or observation window used, treatment of integration and cointegration and level of significance. Statistical criteria may not be very informative about these choices. Third, since the parameters are not structural, the test results may not be stable over different time periods or different countries.

Item Type:Article
Additional Information:This is an electronic version of an article published in "Dunne, John Paul and Smith, Ron P (2010) Military expenditure and Granger causality: A critical review. Defence and Peace Economics, 21 (5-6). pp. 427-441". Defence and Peace Economics is available online at:
Uncontrolled Keywords:military spending, economic growth, causality, VAR
Faculty/Department:Faculty of Business and Law > Department of Accounting, Economics and Finance
ID Code:12149
Deposited By: Professor J. Dunne
Deposited On:06 Jan 2011 09:27
Last Modified:05 Dec 2016 11:04

Request a change to this item

Total Document Downloads in Past 12 Months

Document Downloads

Total Document Downloads

More statistics for this item...