Some may beg to differ: Individual beliefs and group political claims (Keynote Speech)

Lipscomb, M. (2012) Some may beg to differ: Individual beliefs and group political claims (Keynote Speech). In: Philosophy in the Nurse's World: Politics of Nursing Practice II, Banff, Alberta, Canada, 13th - 15th May, 2012. Available from:

[img] Microsoft Word 2007 - Submitted Version
PDF - Submitted Version


Nurses have much to contribute to political discourse and activity. However, to protect and advance this contribution we should perhaps question some of the assumptions underpinning political claims that attach to nurses. In this presentation the group descriptors ‘nurses’ and ‘nursing’ are problematised insofar as these terms depict all nurses. It is suggested that when these descriptors are associated with political claims then forms of group coherence and collective ascription (i.e., the ascription of traits, purposes, values etc., to the group ‘nurses’) are implied which are difficult to sustain. It is proposed that using collective descriptors without adequate explanation/clarity weakens the arguments in which they lodge. Hume’s dismissal of shared value theory is linked with the fallacy of composition and it is suggested that this fallacy is associated with collective ascription error. It is proposed that, while individual nurses and groups of nurses can and do act as intentional political agents we should be wary of claims that insist that nurses collectively do (empiric), should (normative), or must (regulatory) act similarly. If the argument advanced here is accepted then the uPNR (2012) question: “What . . difference . . [does] philosophy make to practice?” will in part have been met. Philosophy here serves a negative-critical function. It challenges the legitimacy of demands placed upon nurses by some nursing scholars and nursing organisations insofar as it undermines the idea that nurses and nursing can own or exhibit a ‘general will’ regards political matters.

Item Type:Conference or Workshop Item (Keynote)
Uncontrolled Keywords:individual beliefs, group political claims
Faculty/Department:Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences > Department of Nursing and Midwifery
Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences
ID Code:16713
Deposited By: Dr M. Lipscomb
Deposited On:08 May 2012 15:55
Last Modified:17 Apr 2017 12:27

Request a change to this item

Total Document Downloads in Past 12 Months

Document Downloads

Total Document Downloads

More statistics for this item...